We Bought the MacBook- Was it Frugal?
Sun 11 Nov 2007, Written by Eden
Categories: Frugality, Spending
As I wrote previously, we recently made plans to purchase a new MacBook for my wife. After much consideration and planning, we made the trip to the Apple store and came home with a shiny, new laptop. This plan generated some good reader comments, both on the aforementioned post and on the post I wrote recently asking, when is it okay to spend money.
I received some support for the purchase and some advice to not go through with it. I think we made a frugal purchase, though I will say it was probably borderline frugal. We could have bought a comparable Windows based laptop for less money, but we really don’t want any more Windows computers and we are already thrilled with the new Mac operating system (Leopard). We also waited for the MacBook hardware upgrades to go through, which happened about a week ago, so we got even more for our money.
Here are the details of the transaction. The retail price for the model we chose is $1,299. However, I work at a University and I saved $100 with my education discount. (Savings -$100)
We added a DVI to VGA adapter for $19, though we noticed that we did not get the education rate of $17 I had seen on the Apple store the day before (I didn’t notice or bring it up as we were paying). (Savings +$2)
Now for an unplanned part of the purchase, it turns out that Apple is offering a $100 rebate when you buy a computer and a printer, conveniently priced at $99.95. We went for that deal since our office printer has been running rather poorly for a while now. That was $100 more than we had planned to spend, yet if I assume we actually get the rebate (I already have it in an envelope ready for the mail) we are really only out the extra sales tax on the printer’s portion of the total. (Savings +$6.10 extra sales tax)
We went to the Apple store outside of the city sales tax area (8.1%), and only had to pay the county tax rate of 6.1%. On a side note, it’s rather sad that the rich part of town has a lower tax rate than the rest of the city, but we used it to our advantage. (Savings -$26.36)
I used my PayPal debit card with 1% cash back bonus to save an extra $13.98 on the final purchase price of $1,398.34. Hopefully we will receive our $100 rebate in 4 - 6 weeks without any problems. The printer is probably the worst part of the deal, but if we actually get the rebate it will turn out to be a good price for what seems to be a good printer (so far).
It is also worth noting that I was ready with an answer of ‘no’ for all of the extras the Apple salesperson was trying to get us to buy. She actually seemed visibly upset that I didn’t want Apple Care or want to pay for some service that would make me ‘first in line’ for the ‘genius bar’. I guess they must get nice commissions on those services, but they should really focus on being more helpful and friendly.
I budgeted $1,400 this month for the MacBook so we managed to stay just below that even with the extra cost of the printer. If the rebate works out as planned, we saved a total of $132.24 for our efforts.
So that’s it. That is our frugal (or extravagant) purchase for the month. I think we got a great quality computer, one that we really wanted and really enjoy. It’s a solid piece of hardware that if we take good care of will give us many years of great service. My wife is already letting her creativity run wild with the incredible software Apple includes for free and I think this is going to be a tremendous help to her at work (she’s a middle school teacher) and it will give her a great deal more flexibility to do her job (lots of grading and planning that she has to do at home).
The frugal/cheap/quality debate will continue- I think we made a wise purchase. What do you think?








November 11th, 2007 at 2:18 pm | Dawn said:
Frank - sounds like you made a well thought out purchase … nothing wrong with that
November 11th, 2007 at 6:25 pm | Clever Dude said:
This is interesting because I’m looking into getting a new Macbook for myself. I’ve never used a Mac (except a decade ago in college), but for what I do, I could easily switch. However, my problem is justifying the high cost for something that has many competitive PC versions for hundreds less.
I do agree with the other comments that it’s a frivolous purchase when you have so much debt, but look at us. We just bought an almost $20k MINI Cooper. We justified it by the fact we didn’t like the Chevy Malibu we had. We have a perfectly working used car my wife could have driven and we could have paid off her student loans with the cash we paid towards the MINI. But we didn’t.
One benefit I get from my employer is $500 towards a new computer ($1000 if you’re there over 5 years). That’s good every 3 years. I haven’t used it yet, and it’s a taxable amount (so about $350 real dollars). I could use that money to justify a macbook, or use it to decrease the price of a very well-equipped PC that’s already cheaper than the macbook.
November 11th, 2007 at 7:23 pm | Frank said:
Hi Clever Dude,
Looking strictly at the cost, a PC definitely wins. However, we’ve fallen in love with the Mac and I’ve never been able to say that about a PC before.
I also really don’t want Windows Vista and any new PCs you buy now are going to have that installed.
I would suggest finding a Mac owner that will let you play around with it a bit and see what you think of the new software and OS. I’m already jealous of my wife and anxious to get my own (after the credit card debt is gone of course).
I work on a Dell laptop that is going on almost five years and it still runs great, but I still plan to switch to a Mac for myself too.
If you want a bargain on a Mac, check out the refurbished and clearance store on the Apple website. The only reason we didn’t do that was the recent hardware upgrade and we wanted to get the newest technology for our money (I’ve found no matter what system I buy I always wish I had bought something faster after a while).
November 11th, 2007 at 7:25 pm | Frank said:
@Dawn - thanks for the support!
November 11th, 2007 at 7:35 pm | Mrs. Micah said:
Well, there are some things you just need–and you spent responsibly. If it wasn’t frugal it was at least a good purchase. Plus you planned and budgeted.
November 11th, 2007 at 7:41 pm | Frank said:
Hi Mrs. Micah,
Thanks for stopping by. I guess if I’m completely honest, a cheaper laptop would have met our NEEDS, so we mixed in some WANTS on this purchase, but we didn’t go too far out of bounds- I hope. My goal was to at least plan it out and make the best purchase I could, even if it wasn’t an absolute necessity.
November 12th, 2007 at 7:21 am | Joe S said:
Couple of suggestions here - you NEVER buy a laptop from the maker of the laptop and you ABSOLUTELY NEVER buy a laptop which does not have a warranty for atleast one year.
I have always bought my laptop off of ebay - from reputable sellers with tons of warranty. I ususally save 15-20% of store price.
I have also had 4 laptops over the years from different manufacturers and ALL have had something go wrong with them. Without the warranty service, I would be out of some serious cash. I would highly recommend that you go and get Apple Care for your mac…
November 12th, 2007 at 7:29 am | Frank said:
Hey Joe S,
I appreciate your perspective, but my history has been the opposite of yours.
I’ve owned 2 desktops and 2 laptops over the last 8-10 years and never needed warranty service of any kind. That’s why I don’t buy it and why I like to buy new machines- I know that I’ll take good care of it and not have any problems. Sure things can still break and I may just be lucky so far, but I’ve decided to take the risk.
The Mac warranty is 1 year and I can buy Apple Care up to a year after I bought the laptop if I want it. For things like computers, I’d rather self-insure though.
November 13th, 2007 at 2:28 pm | TMM said:
I’ve had a macbook since last June and I’ve had to send it in twice for repair already (once for a crack in the cover due to the magnet and once for the infamous orange staining on the palm rest). Both times I’ve gotten it back within a few days with overnight shipping. I bought the extended AppleCare because I got an additional discount as a college student, but with a first gen Mac laptop, I think it was a good investment.
November 13th, 2007 at 6:45 pm | Frank said:
Hey TMM, good point with the first gen hardware- that is probably a great time to buy the extended warranty. I felt a little better about getting the latest chipset, santa rosa I think it’s called, so hopefully it will be more stable now. I do get the student rate on AppleCare too and I could still buy it, but I don’t think I will.